1862: Edmund Findlay Churchill to Charlotte (Churchill) Plummer

This letter was written by Edmund Findlay Churchill (1842-1921) of Co. E, 18th Massachusetts Infantry. Edmund enlisted on 9 August 1862 and served in the same company as his twin brother, Isaiah F. Churchill, and another brother, Frederick (“Fred”) S. Churchill, who was killed in action at 2nd Bull Run. Edmund Churchill was with his regiment at Antietam, Shepherdstown and Fredericksburg. He was a Color Bearer for the regiment and one of 11 men of Company E cited for their courage at the battle of Fredericksburg by Lt. Col. Joseph Hayes, regimental commander. He was promoted to the rank of Sergeant on 1 May 1863. He was further engaged with the regiment in 1863 at Chancellorsville, Gettysburg, and Rappahannock Station. He was again engaged in the Overland Campaign from 1 May 1864, including the Battle of the Wilderness. He was wounded at the battle of Laurel Hill, Virginia on 8 May 1864, when struck in the head by a ricocheting bullet and knocked unconscious by the concussion of a shell. He was mustered out of military service on 2 September 1864 at the expiration of his three-year enlistment.

Edmund mentions his younger brother, Theodore (“Teddy”) Parker Churchill of Co. A, 32nd Massachusetts Infantry, who died at Falmouth, Virginia, of fever on 14 December 1862. He addresses the letter to his sister who was probably Charlotte Parker Churchill (b. 1835), the wife of David Sumner Plummer, and a resident of Plympton.

They were all the children of Isaiah Churchill (1806-1880) and Polly Stevens Parker (1809-1894) of Plympton, Plymouth County, Massachusetts.

In this letter, Edmund describes being under fire at a creek crossing in action at Sheperdstown, Virginia, during Lee’s retreat from Antietam. Most of the letter, however, is devoted to sharing with his family what he had learned to date of the disappearance of his younger brother, Fred Churchill, at the Battle of 2d Bull Run.


Camp in Maryland nearly opposite Shepardstown, Virginia
October 1st 1862

Dear Sister,

I received your letter of September 21st night before last and take this opportunity to answer it. I also received at the same time letters from Aunt Jane, cousin Sarah L. H. and Angeline E. Ellis.

I will tell you now before I write anymore all that I know about Fred. I have enquired of all that I think would know anything about it and can find only one who remembers of seeing Fred after the retreat commenced. This was a Mr. [William S.] Walker of our company — the same Lieutenant [that] Winsor wrote you about. He says that after the regiment had begun to fall back, he passed Fred and said to him, “Come, Fred, are you not going to fall back?” Fred was about ten feet from him then. He had not ceased firing as I understand Mr. Walker to say. Fred said, “Yes,” and came after him. A little way from there, there was a ditch they had to cross on the retreat. Mr. Walker says he saw Fred just before crossing the ditch but did not see Fred cross or see him after this. This is all that I can find out about him although, as you may suppose, I have made every inquiry that I think would be of any use. I cannot learn as any other person saw him after the retreat began. He was not wounded then and of course we know not whether he was after or not.

You say in your letter of the 21st September as follows, “In one letter you say “wounded in side by piece of shell.” I think one of us have made a mistake — either myself in writing or you in reading. It was John Jordan ¹ who was wounded in the side and I should have said so, If I did not, it is a mistake of mine as I never understood that Fred was hurt at all. But I do know that he was not when the retreat commenced. This is all I can tell you. I would not withhold anything from your knowledge be it ever so good or bad.

You ask several questions which I will answer as best I can. The retreat was not until near night. Our ambulances did not go to the field until the next day as it was not possible, and this may lead you to enquire, “Why did they not go that night?” I will tell you. The ambulances are kept in the rear of the army during an action and it takes some time for them to come up. Then a flag of truce must pass over for permission for troops to bury our dead and take off wounded. That is the reason our wounded were not taken off sooner.

You say I little realize the suspense Father and you are in in regard to Fred. Perhaps I do not. As to myself, you know I have always been in the habit of taking things as calmly as possible and now I must say that I do not look on the dark side at all but all the time I hope for the best. If I should give way to feelings here, it would do no good. But at the same time, I feel for Fred and think of his situation as much perhaps as you do. But it does no one any good to look at the dark side. I can write no more about him now but if I hear anymore from him, you shall know immediately.

I have been to visit the 32nd [Massachusetts] boys this afternoon. Teddy is enjoying pretty good health at present. He looks hardy and tough, just as if he could go through with considerable hard work. All the others are well as usual. Frank & I are getting along first rate enjoying a tolerable good share of health.

You say “I never never ever would give my consent to your going near this accursed war were you at home now.” Do not feel so. You could not refuse my going now more were I there & wished to go, could you now. I have been in [a] fight but once as yet [and] perhaps shall never again. But if I do, I am determined no one shall see me hold back or show that I am afraid to face the greybacks. They are no enemy at all in an open field but will fight well if they get the advantage of us in position. The fight I was in was across the river one week ago Saturday. In retreating, the Rebs pelted us well as we crossed the river. The water would now and then leap up around us as a ball struck it. Still few were hurt in crossing.

It’s getting dark here and I must stop soon. Mrs. White’s letters have been received for which you can assure her she has my warmest thanks. Although a stranger to me yet, her friendship for you makes me feel almost as though I heard from you when she writes. I hope she will take the trouble to write again. If I can possibly answer her letters, I will do so but under present circumstances I cannot write home more than once where I would like to 3 or 4 times. We have no conveniences for writing here. To send you these few scribbles, I had to borrow paper, ink, pen, envelope, and stamp.

Remember me to Bradford K & wife & grandma. Love to all reserving a good share for yourself. From your brother, — Edmund F. Churchill

¹ John Jordan of Plympton, Massachusetts, died on 14 September 1862 of the wound he received at 2nd Bull Run.



One Comment Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s